Argentina May Risk Investment as Lawmakers Seek Profit Sharing

Argentina’s government is pushing a bill that would require companies to distribute 10 percent of profits to employees, a move business leaders say violates property rights and may undermine investment in South America’s second-biggest economy.

Hector Recalde, a 72-year-old lawmaker for President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner’s Victory Front alliance, said his bill would allow employees to benefit from the surging profits at banks and other industries. Opponents say it would dissuade companies from expanding, buying new equipment and adding jobs. The Labor Committee in Argentina’s lower house will take up the legislation this week.

“Argentina urgently needs more investments and this is going to generate a totally negative effect on jobs,” said Diego Perez Santisteban, president of Argentina’s Importers Chamber. “It can inhibit those who have plans to invest.”

The proposal, which opposition leaders said they can support, comes as banks, telecommunications companies and food producers benefit from the country’s economic growth. Argentina’s economy will grow 9 percent this year, the most since 2005, according to the central bank’s forecast, after 0.9 percent growth last year. The plan may boost trade union support for Fernandez ahead of presidential elections next October, said Analia Del Franco, a political analyst who runs pollster Analogias in Buenos Aires.

Union Support

“In Argentina, the capacity to govern is closely related to the control and support that the government has from the unions,” Del Franco said in a telephone interview.

Recalde’s proposal cites similar legislation in countries such as Mexico, where companies have to share 10 percent of their profits, as well as laws in Brazil, Chile and Peru.

Nine years after Argentina defaulted on a record $95 billion in debt, foreign direct investment in the country is among the lowest in South America’s major economies, totaling $2.2 billion in the first half of 2010 compared with $17.1 billion in Brazil, $8 billion in Chile, $4.1 billion in Colombia and $3.4 billion in Peru, according to the Santiago-based United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America.

Companies may be further discouraged from putting more money into Argentina if this bill passes, said Bertrand Delgado, an economist at Roubini Global Economics LLC in New York.

Property Rights

The bill “clashes with the constitutional principles of property rights,” the Argentine Industrial Union, which represents the country’s biggest companies, said in an Oct. 25 statement. It comes “at a time when the country needs very strong growth in investments to generate more jobs and development.”

The backdrop of climbing profits at banks and other companies makes this an ideal time to pass the bill, Recalde said in an interview.

“This system will bring more investment,” said Recalde, who has worked as a lawyer for the country’s biggest labor union, in an interview in Buenos Aires. “What could be a better advertisement for our country than showing the high rates of profitability that companies are having?”

Consumer spending in Argentina rose 8.1 percent in the second quarter from the same period a year earlier, auto production is heading to an all-time high and farmers have reaped a record soybean harvest of 55 million tons. The economy expanded 8.5 percent in August from a year earlier and the benchmark Merval stock index has climbed 44 percent this year, compared with 5.9 percent for Brazil’s Bovespa Index and 38 percent for Chile’s Ipsa.

Fernandez said Nov. 5 that unemployment fell to 7.6 percent in the third quarter from 7.9 percent in the second quarter.

Rising Profits

Profits at Argentine banks rose 43 percent in the first eight months of the year to 6.68 billion pesos, according to an Oct. 21 report by the central bank. Last year, banks profits rose 66 percent to 7.92 billion pesos.

Telecom Argentina SA, the country’s second-largest telephone company, said profit rose 47 percent in the third quarter from a year earlier on higher sales of Internet and wireless services.

Lawmakers from the ruling coalition as well as opposition leaders such as Margarita Stolbizer and Federico Pinedo said they are open to changing the percentage of profits that must be shared and the role of unions in examining company accounts.

“We aim to achieve cooperation between businessmen and workers to assure productivity, competitiveness, job creation and good salaries,” Stolbizer said in an e-mail.

Majority Control

Opposition blocs have a majority in the lower house of congress, while the Senate is closely divided.

Recalde’s measure also aims to give unions and workers the right to examine their employers’ accounting to ensure that they’re getting a fair share of profits. That would create an untenable situation in which workers will try to “co- administer” companies, said Santisteban, of the importers’ chamber.

Companies don’t “want to have a discussion with unions about projects where they put capital at risk,” he said.

The Industrial Union wants to modify the bill so that unions, which represent about 80 percent of Argentina’s registered workers, can’t view the companies’ books or bring up the issue of profit sharing during annual wage negotiations.

The profit-sharing requirement would initially apply only to companies with at least 300 employees. It would eventually be expanded to all businesses that meet a certain level of profitability, with the details to be determined by a committee of government officials, union members and business executives.

‘Revolutionary Bill’

Hugo Moyano, the leader of the General Labor Confederation, the country’s biggest union, urged lawmakers to approve what he called a “revolutionary bill” during an Oct. 15 rally in Buenos Aires with President Fernandez.

“Companies have never earned so much money as they do now,” Moyano said.

Eduardo Gutierrez, president of Grupo Farallon, a Buenos Aires-based construction company that employees 600 workers, said in an interview that he doesn’t want to be forced to share his earnings.

“I have thought about this idea for my company many times, but it should be optional,” Gutierrez said.

To contact the reporter on this story: Eliana Raszewski in Buenos Aires at [email protected]

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Joshua Goodman at [email protected]

Sponsored Links

Market Snapshot 

  • U.S.
  • Europe
  • Asia
Ticker Price Price Delta
Dow 11357.00 +10.29 (0.09%)
S&P; 500 1218.71 +5.31 (0.44%)
Nasdaq 2578.78 +15.80 (0.62%)
Ticker Price Price Delta
STOXX 50 2831.56 -14.37 (-0.50%)
FTSE 100 5804.11 -12.83 (-0.22%)
DAX 6709.42 -10.42 (-0.16%)
Ticker Price Price Delta
Nikkei 9861.46 +30.94 (0.31%)
TOPIX 856.37 +3.39 (0.40%)
Hang Seng 24700.30 +199.69 (0.82%)

Advertisement

Advertisements

Sponsored Links