Bank of America Awaits Ruling On Social Security Case Payout By CARRICK MOLLENKAMP and NICOLE HARRIS Staff Reporters of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
A California judge will decide whether Bank of AmericaCorp. should have to pay as much as $1 billion to customers who allege that the bank mishandled their Social Security deposits. A jury in San Francisco on Wednesday found in favor of a class of about one million customers and ruled that each customer who was harmed by the bank should be paid $1,000. The chief claim was that Bank of America inappropriately used Social Security payments to pay for customer fees and overdrafts. Whether Bank of America actually will have to pay $1 billion remains unknown. Superior Court Judge Ann Bouliane in San Francisco is expected to decide how many in the class should be paid and how much. The jury separately awarded the plaintiffs $75 million. Shirley Norton, a Bank of America spokeswoman, said the Charlotte, N.C., bank plans to appeal. "We think the whole suit is without merit," Ms. Norton said. The case stems from a 1998 dispute between Bank of America and Paul Miller, a bank customer and a disabled former photojournalist who was receiving direct-deposit Social Security benefits in a Bank of America account. (The dispute arose before NationsBank Corp. of Charlotte, N.C., acquired BankAmerica Corp., San Francisco, in September 1998 to create Bank of America Corp.) Mr. Miller alleged that because of a mistake by the bank, his checking account was overdrawn. The bank subsequently used Social Security deposits to cover the overdrawn account. The lawyers for Mr. Miller ultimately pursued a class action on behalf of Mr. Miller and others who allegedly had their Social Security deposits used to cover fees and overdrafts. The plaintiffs claimed that Social Security deposits were exempt from covering overdrafts, insufficient-fund charges and other bank debts.
|